Quite possibly one of the most interesting and controversial talks at GDC this year was by Professor Brian Moriarty who defended Ebert in his belief that games are not what he calls “Sublime Art”. Below is a recording and a transcript of the lecture.
Good afternoon.(cheers)
Well this is an easy crowd. (laughs)
I am, in fact, Professor Moriarty. (more cheers)
The title of this lecture, “An Apology for Roger Ebert,” may require a bit of clarification.
I’m not here to offer an apology in the sense of regret for anything done wrong.
This is an apology in the sense of a Greek apologia, the systematic defense of a position or opinion.
It’s a defense of Roger Ebert, the Pulitzer Prize winning film critic for the Chicago Sun-Times who, a little over five years ago, annoyed our industry by declaring that “video games can never be art.”
For those few of you unacquainted with this controversy, I’ll spend just a few minutes recounting what happened.



